click here



The Blue Room


Tinka's New Dress


Great Expectations



Feature Articles:

Andrew O'Hagan

Peter Temple

Adib Khan

Vikram Seth

Love in the Age of Therapy

Cyndi O'Meara


Leona Mitchell


Travel Stories:




Mt. Buffalo



The Power of the Sun

Life Behind Bars

Political Correctness

My Boss


Book Reviews:

Ben Hills

Anne Jacobs

Elaine Lewis

Anne Jacobs

ALIEN ROOTS A German Jewish girlhood: From belonging to exile

by Anne Jacobs (Makor Jewish Community Library)

Review by Carol Middleton, published as A Wider Eye in Australian Book Review, May 2007

Alien Roots is a remarkable memoir, written in Melbourne by a German Jew, Anne Jacobs (born Annemarie Meyer), in the 1960s at a time when the Holocaust was rarely mentioned in Australia. It has been published by the Melbourne-based Makor Jewish Community Library thirty-nine years after it was written and many years after the writer's death in 1982. Charles Jacobs collated and distributed his wife's memoir for the family, and her children arranged for its publication at the end of last year.

The memoir is remarkable for its wealth of detail. The author is able to recall the precise events and characters in her early life as a schoolgirl in the late 1920s and 1930s, in spite of the fact that these occurred thirty to forty years prior to writing the memoir. She evokes a vivid picture of Germany between the wars, struggling to survive under the shadow of the Treaty of Versailles. Writing from the point of view of a young Jew in an assimilated Hannover family, Jacobs describes the slow but relentless changing of attitudes towards Jews in those times. She succeeds in recapturing the feeling she had as a child of being immune to Nazi racism, not only because of the fact that her family were non-practising Jews, but also because, like most Jewish German families, they had become fully integrated into German society and consciousness over several generations.

At the same time as recalling this child's point of view, Jacobs uses the benefit of hindsight to give us a clear historical perspective on the rise of the Nazi party, the reasons for its popularity and its acceptance by the majority of Germans. Alien Roots follows the story of how Jacobs grew to maturity in an increasingly alienating environment. Through the story of this one woman we read the wider story of the Jewish race in Germany in the lead-up to World War II.

At the same time, this memoir gives more than an insight into pre-war Germany. There are memories of schools that she attended in England and Belgium, which help flesh out a broader picture of pre-war Europe. Jacobs' mother sent her to England to be educated in a progressive co-educational boarding school that encouraged independent thought, a move that was anathema to Jacobs, who had been brought up in a disciplined German Gymnasium where children had narrow views and were not encouraged to discuss adult issues such as religion and politics. In contrast, her subsequent schooling at a Catholic convent in Belgium, with its strict but protective cloistered existence, was welcomed by Jacobs, especially as the world outside was becoming an increasingly threatening place.

The most poignant moment in the memoir, one that acts as a turning point in the story, is her return to Germany after her year of homesickness in England, to find that her idyllic German childhood is a thing of the past and that her schoolgirl friendships are over. In spite of her efforts and those of her close friends, nothing will ever be the same again for Jews in Germany. Her friends have become part of the new German youth. The changes that take place in these childhood friendships illuminate the changing allegiances that were taking place in the adult world.

Alien Roots is written without any literary pretention, in clear precise prose. Jacobs' command of the English language, in spite of the fact that it was not her native tongue, is excellent. This, her only long work, has a fine sense of rhythm. The 400 pages are easy to read. The writer has a distinctive voice, depicting every character in her family with sympathy but objectivity, including her own character as a child who was quick to anger, stubborn and determined to get her own way. She writes with a sharp sense of humour, a retrospective irony, a lightness of touch and no trace of self-pity. The most harrowing events are told in a single sentence, all the more searing because of their brevity.

On a personal level, Alien Roots was without doubt a way for Jacobs to capture all that was precious to her as a child growing up in Germany: the Eilenriede wood in the heart of Hannover; the magical Christmases that her assimilated Jewish family enjoyed; the huge and enchanting house and garden of her paternal grandmother. These were all lost to her when the Nazis came to power. She conveys her love of Germany and her early deeply felt nationalistic feelings during group outings to the countryside, her participation in the harsh, brooding nature mystique that was unique to Germany and found expression in folk singing, camping, hiking and rural films. This belief in the sacredness of German soil gave Hitler an easy ride to power and it was a faith that Jacobs shared until she started to identify consciously with her Jewish roots and become one of the dispossessed.

Jacobs emigrated to Australia in 1940, thanks to the fact that her grandmother had been born in Australia. She married and lived in Melbourne with her husband and children, but this part of her life is not touched on in Alien Roots, which ends as she leaves Germany for England at the end of 1937 at the age of nineteen to enter the business world. This is more than a personal memoir. It seems that Jacobs' priority was to convey her insights into those pivotal years in Jewish and German history. She could contemplate the pre-war years from a distance and put down on paper the memories of those years that marked her childhood and record an experience of Fascism that was unique to her but that adds a valuable insight into the predicament of German Jews as a whole.











website design by hive